Jump down to beginning of page content

The Business of a Better World

Blog


Publication Date

November 8, 2011

Share



Is Business Ready for Hypertransparency?

In the age of Wikileaks, the Arab Spring, and Occupy Wall Street, technology has opened a new world for democratized digital inclusion. Suddenly, there is more information available instantly—to everyone, everywhere—about environmental degradation, human rights impacts, and ethical business practices.

This new data-saturated culture in which technology allows messages—both true and false—to spread like wildfire is forcing a shift in the transparency paradigm. The era of controlled and packaged disclosures is giving way to transparency that is being co-created by stakeholders and citizen journalists. And businesses, ready or not, will have to adapt.

But this adaptation isn't always easy or fast. While 55 percent of sustainable business leaders in a new BSR/GlobeScan survey say increased transparency is critical to improving public trust, only 32 percent believe business is showing leadership in this area.

At last week's BSR Conference 2011, panelists and participants in a session on hypertransparency echoed this sentiment. They pointed to the immense opportunity for building greater trust, engagement, and empowerment through co-created transparency. But they also grappled with how to create accountability for the abundance of new information, the challenge of lasting engagement in 140-character attention spans, and whether we have to sacrifice privacy for transparency.

Despite the uncertainties, a few companies are bravely tiptoeing into this arena:

These are promising first steps, but it’s important to remember that transparency in itself is not the end game. It's not enough to just put the information and data out there. To engender trust, businesses need to also engage with their stakeholders to help them filter and understand the information without acting as a censor or dumbing down the content.

The power and potential in hypertransparency is the opportunity to co-create solutions. If business is able to move from one-way disclosures to a continuous communication and engagement model, the exchange of products and services can create contact, friendships, and emotional accountability from corporations to consumers around the world.

This article is also published on the Huffington Post.

Share Your Thoughts

Please note, all comments are subject to moderation. All fields are required but your email address will not be published.



Please notify me of follow-up comments via my email address.


Comments

On November 8, 2011, Cathie Guthrie, wrote:

Naomi, I’m glad you recognized the importance of emotional connectivity as an attribute of the relationship which will only result from engagement that is responsive and meaningful. I think consumers have a genuine curiosity to gain a fuller appreciation for what it is a company does and interest then, in supporting companies with whom they can connect, with whom they share the same values. This emotional connection is only really felt once there is a deeper understanding for what it is that’s being done and how it is being done. Company2Keep http://c2k.co/22f launched a destination website quite recently to fulfill this demand for transparency. We’re still populating the site before opening the doors to wider public scrutiny and we’re thrilled by the response of companies who recognize another richer dimension of their relationship with stakeholders. We have a video demo queued up on our landing page to demonstrate the site’s features and their functionality for anyone interested in checking it out. Our aim is to fill that appetite of curiosity with transparency and engagement opportunity. There was a terrific blog post http://c2k.co/Lz last week by Chris MacDonald (@ethicsblogger) about Walmart Canada’s CSR report, reacting as he did by saying, the purpose is “not to show that you are doing everything right, but to show what you are doing." The worry seems to be that everything described in a report must be perceived as “right” if the company is to secure a passing grade. On the contrary, there may be greater reputation risk when only some aspects of business are addressed in a CSR report. Suspicions are immediately aroused when it is believed the whole story is not being told and that something has been deliberately omitted from a report.

Comments

On November 8, 2011, Naomi Mandelstein, wrote:

Thanks for the link, Cathie. And I agree with your points about letting your sustainability story be messy. Providing transparency into the challenges is actually a great opportunity to co-create solutions. See Melanie's post on that topic: http://www.bsr.org/en/our-insights/blog-view/how-to-tell-your-sustainability-story-the-messier-the-better

Comments

On November 8, 2011, Cathie Guthrie, wrote:

Thanks for the link to Melanie's post. I don't know how I missed it previously. I love the reference to "sharing the ride, not simply celebrating the arrival." I'm simply charmed by "the living case study is open to input, questions, reflections, and most of all, empowerment of peers.” Thanks for enriching our dialogue!

Publications

Blog

Opinions, ideas, and notes from the field from BSR staff members around the world.

BSR Insight 

A weekly member-only email newsletter, providing members with expert insights, tools, and analysis on timely global sustainability topics.

BSR Review

A collection of articles, research reports, and opinion pieces written or developed by BSR Sustainable Investment in China Newsletter: Helping investors support sustainable businesses, and helping businesses attract and engage these investors.

Case Studies

Snapshots of our impact working with business to create a just and sustainable world.

Research Reports

Independent, business-critical research to help you stay ahead of the curve and advance corporate responsibility.

Sustainable Investment in China

A quarterly newsletter will help investors in China understand how sustainable investing can mitigate business risk and create opportunities for greater financial as well as social and environmental returns.

Sustainability Matters 

Snapshots of our impact working with business to create a just and sustainable world.

 BSR member-only content; valid login required.


About the Author