Jump down to beginning of page content


Aron Cramer

Aron Cramer, President and CEO

Publication Date

January 27, 2012


Letter to the New York Times From BSR

Earlier this week, BSR asked the New York Times to correct inaccurate and misleading information in the story that ran on January 26, 2012 entitled “In China, the Human Costs That Are Built Into an iPad.” Here we present our letter to the editor that we submitted following publication of the article, as well as the main points we made to the New York Times in a letter sent on January 17, prior to publication. While some changes were made to the story, we believe that several important inaccuracies and misleading information remained in the story that was published on January 26.

Dear Editors,

I am writing in response to The New York Times article “In China, the Human Costs That Are Built Into an iPad,” published on January 26  by Charles Duhigg and David Barboza.

This article shines a light on important supply chain issues that are a crucial part of the global economy—one of the sustainability challenges BSR has worked on with business and other stakeholders for 20 years. Unfortunately, the article mistakenly attributes several quotes to an unnamed “BSR consultant,” presenting a false impression that those views should be associated with BSR.

While the story focuses on Apple, the question of conditions in global supply chains is of immense importance to all companies, in all sectors. There is no doubt that, while more and more companies are committed to ensuring good working conditions in their supply chains, additional steps should be taken. The key to progress is a combination of renewed commitments by the private sector, better enforcement of laws by governments, collaboration between businesses and NGOs, and worker empowerment. Global companies who are active in this space know that long-term, sustainable change takes time and requires many players working together.

This goes to the heart of our work at BSR. We remain intensely committed to helping global companies work effectively with government, consumers, workers, and civil society to create a more sustainable future.

Aron Cramer
President and CEO, BSR

Summary of BSR’s pre-publication letter to the New York Times on January 17, 2012.

The following is a summary of the main points we made to the New York Times on January 17, in response to information about the story that we were provided prior to publication.

There are several areas where the text you provided us is inaccurate and therefore presents an inaccurate account of events you aim to describe.

BSR does not believe that Apple has consistently disregarded its advice.

  1. It is untrue that Apple has consistently disregarded advice that BSR has provided about problems related to working conditions in its supply chain.
  2. The account of the pilot project in south China omits and obscures key facts. Despite the publication of a report that has been in the public domain for several years, there are errors in how you present the project conducted under the auspices of the World Bank, BSR, and three other sponsors.
  3. Your attribution of several opinions about Apple to BSR misstates the views of the organization. In several places, you attribute certain opinions about Apple to an unnamed “BSR consultant,” despite the fact that this consultant is unnamed, and are not affiliated with BSR. Associating these views with BSR is a serious misrepresentation, and should be changed.

The narrative you present is an inaccurate picture of the work we have done with Apple, of the role Apple played in the worker hotline project, and of BSR’s views of Apple.

A copy of BSR’s complete letter submitted to the New York Times on January 17, 2012 is available by PDF for download.



Opinions, ideas, and notes from the field from BSR staff members around the world.

BSR Insight

A weekly member-only email newsletter, providing members with expert insights, tools, and analysis on timely global sustainability topics.

BSR Review

A collection of articles, research reports, and opinion pieces written or developed by BSR Sustainable Investment in China Newsletter: Helping investors support sustainable businesses, and helping businesses attract and engage these investors.

Case Studies

Snapshots of our impact working with business to create a just and sustainable world.

Research Reports

Independent, business-critical research to help you stay ahead of the curve and advance corporate responsibility.

Sustainable Investment in China

A quarterly newsletter will help investors in China understand how sustainable investing can mitigate business risk and create opportunities for greater financial as well as social and environmental returns.

Sustainability Matters 

Snapshots of our impact working with business to create a just and sustainable world.

 BSR member-only content; valid login required.

Share Your Thoughts

Please note, all comments are subject to moderation.

About the Author(s)

Aron Cramer

Aron Cramer , President and CEO

Aron is recognized globally as a preeminent authority on corporate responsibility and sustainability strategy by business, NGOs, and the public sector... Read more →


No topics for this entry

Related Content