Empowering Women in Toy Factories: Insights from Our Pilot in India

Pixabay / FeeLoona

September 5, 2019
  • Lucia Flores Guevara

    Former Manager, BSR

If you are buying a toy for your child, niece, or nephew, it was most likely made by a woman in China or India. Indeed, women make up over 60 percent of the global toy manufacturing workforce and are critical to its success. However, low-income women working at toy factories can face gender discrimination, harassment, and poor health conditions.

BSR and the Ethical Toy Program (ETP) collaborated on a women’s empowerment program that was piloted in three toy factories in India with a total population of 824 workers—including 198 women. The program, funded by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands, consisted of in-factory trainings on gender awareness, health, communications, and prevention of gender-based violence delivered to ‘Core Groups’ comprised of managers, HR staff, and frontline workers.  Core Group members were also in charge of driving actions for gender equality and disseminating the learnings to the entire workforce.

From the pilots, we gained several insights into what it takes to develop successful programs to advance women in the workplace:

  • Partner with an organization that has a deep understanding of the local context and can build trust with the factory. We worked with Kshitij, an Indian NGO with knowledge of the local gender norms, to deliver the program. At the beginning of the pilot, factories were skeptical of the relevance of a women’s empowerment program for their business. However, Kshitij’s extensive experience with workplace-based interventions and a clear communication of the business and social benefits of the program ensured the factories’ buy-in.
  • Consult beneficiaries before program design to tailor it to their needs and encourage program ownership by having beneficiaries define their own priorities. Interviews with workers informed program design and, at the beginning of the pilot, members of the Core Groups completed a questionnaire to assess the factory’s strengths and gaps on gender equity and equality. To encourage honest answers, sharing the results was optional. Guided by their assessment score, Core Groups defined the issues to tackle through an action plan.
  • Ensure meaningful engagement with men to achieve sustainable gender norm transformation. The Core Groups comprised of both women and men that engaged on critical reflections around gender norms that reinforce patriarchy and inequality. As they begun to understand what they could gain by shifting these harmful norms, they became eager to share their learnings with their peers and their families.

As India is an emerging sourcing destination, the largest toy factories in the country employ only a few hundred workers, compared to factories located in established toy manufacturing centers such as China which can employ many thousands of workers. The factories that participated in the pilot were family-owned and were new to women’s empowerment and social sustainability standards. Despite the experience being different for each of the factories, we saw common changes across the whole pilot. These outcomes are encouraging for factories and buyers who want to invest in women even at the beginning of their journey.

One outcome we saw across the three factories was an increased understanding of and commitment to gender equality and worker well-being among factory management, supervisors, and workers through the provision of in-factory training. This translated into all three factories creating or strengthening policies to prevent sexual harassment, in compliance with India’s POSH Act, reinforcing their grievance mechanisms, and increasing awareness of these amongst workers.

These outcomes are encouraging for factories and buyers who want to invest in women even at the beginning of their journey.

The pilot also resulted in greater awareness on menstrual hygiene and increased use of sanitary napkins. Prior the training, it was common for women workers to use cloth during menstrual cycles. By realizing that period poverty was exposing women to serious infections, the factories decided to provide subsidized sanitary napkins to the workers. That, coupled with the efforts to debunk the taboo of menstruation, increased the reported usage of sanitary napkins among women by a factor of eight and, more surprisingly, led to men advocating for their use to the women in their family.

Though the trainings were conducted in the workplace, the program helped improve workers’  communication and relationships both at work and at home. Before the trainings, women would hesitate to approach their male coworkers. The focus on assertive communications and tackling deep-rooted gender stereotypes led to better interactions between workers and supervisors of the opposite sex. It also led to greater confidence, as explained by one woman frontline worker that was part of the Core Group, “I spread awareness on health and hygiene among my peers at work and home. This process has given me immense confidence, I now plan to study again to realize my dream of becoming a teacher.” 

In addition, before the intervention, participants rated their relationships at home with an average of three, on a scale from zero to 10, with 10 being the highest. After program completion, the average rating was nine. Some men attributed the improvement to their engagement in household work. “Before I never helped my wife with household chores,” one worker explained. “Now, instead of blaming her, I cook breakfast if she is busy. I have become more considerate towards her.”

The program made all participants aware of the existing services to prevent violence against women at work and in their community. 

Lastly, the feedback we received showed that the program helped to decrease acceptance of violence against women and increase awareness on how to address violence. Prior to the program, participants rated their understanding of sexual harassment with an average of three out of 10, and they reported no awareness of available services to approach in case of violence. After program completion, the average rating had risen to eight. The program made all participants aware of the existing services to prevent violence against women at work and in their community. Even more, some participants also re-evaluated their abusive behavior. One male worker noted, “The trainings made me realize how insensitive I was. Now, instead of insisting, I wait for my wife’s consent when it comes to intimacy. Respect and communication are very important in a relationship.”

Factory owners, managers, and workers that were once skeptical about the intervention are now championing women’s empowerment in the workplace—and also within the wider toy industry in India and their own communities. Looking ahead, BSR and ETP will explore opportunities to scale the program in China to reach thousands more women, as well as using the learnings of this pilot to inform BSR’s initiatives on women’s empowerment, such as the HERproject.

Collaborative Initiatives

Let’s talk about how BSR can help you to transform your business and achieve your sustainability goals.

Contact Us