Jump down to beginning of page content

Blog


David Korngold

David Korngold, Manager, Advisory Services

John Hodges

John Hodges, Director, Financial Services

Publication Date

December 20, 2012

Share



What Cerberus’ Firearm Divestment Says About Private Equity and Social Responsibility

David Korngold, Associate, Advisory Services, and John Hodges, Director, Financial Services, BSR

In the wake of the tragedy in Newtown, Connecticut, headlines in the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal have focused on the private equity firm Cerberus, a leading investor in the firearms industry. On Monday, the California State Teachers’ Retirement System (CalSTRS), a major investor in Cerberus, joined calls by pundits for the firm to rethink the social responsibility of its investment in the Freedom Group, which owns gun brands Bushmaster and Remington. On Tuesday, Cerberus announced it would sell its stake in the company.

This is only the latest story to highlight the social responsibility of private equity firms, following a year of headlines about Mitt Romney’s work at Bain Capital. Cerberus’ Freedom Group divestment also the demonstrated the real-time, rapid-response influence of a private equity firm’s major limited partners (LPs).

There are four important lessons that private equity firms can take from these events:

  1. Firms should adopt more formal policies for sectors and geographies with high environmental, social, and governance (ESG) risks. For example, many investment banks have publicly disclosed lending policies covering environmental and socially sensitive sectors, such as arms and cluster munitions, natural resource extraction, and forestry. Similarly, private equity firms should look for ways to adopt formal ESG policies to guide their participation in high-risk areas.
  2. Firms often lag behind other investor classes in transparency and reporting. BSR’s recent publication, “Reporting on Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Considerations in the Private Equity Sector,” focused on how private equity firms measure, monitor, and disclose ESG issues. Although ESG issues are increasingly on the agenda for LPs and the general partners (GPs) who manage firms, BSR found that the quantity and quality of ESG reporting by GPs often fails to meet investor and stakeholder interests. While a limited number of firms (such as KKR and the Carlyle Group) publish sustainability reports, it’s time for the rest of the sector to catch up and report on ESG impacts.
  3. LPs are increasingly adopting their own ESG management and transparency policies.  As Anne Simpson, CalPERS' senior portfolio manager for corporate governance, noted in a 2012 interview: “Our view is that ESG factors ought to be a routine part of the financial reports that companies make.” To meet those expectations and develop stronger relationships with LPs, private equity firms should consider how they can better develop and disclose their own ESG management strategies to LPs.
  4. “S” is lagging “E” and “G.”  While some firms have more experience with environmental and governance issues, social issues are playing a bigger role in ESG analysis. Private equity firms are exposed to the social risks—community impacts, labor practices, and more—of all sectors in which they invest. That’s why BSR is collaborating with EDF on a new ESG Management Tool for Private Equity, which provides a comprehensive framework for assessing and improving ESG performance in the private equity investment process and portfolio management. BSR and EDF will be partnering in 2013 on a variety of events to help private equity firms improve their ESG analysis.

Publications

Blog

Opinions, ideas, and notes from the field from BSR staff members around the world.

BSR Insight

A weekly member-only email newsletter, providing members with expert insights, tools, and analysis on timely global sustainability topics.

BSR Review

A collection of articles, research reports, and opinion pieces written or developed by BSR Sustainable Investment in China Newsletter: Helping investors support sustainable businesses, and helping businesses attract and engage these investors.

Case Studies

Snapshots of our impact working with business to create a just and sustainable world.

Research Reports

Independent, business-critical research to help you stay ahead of the curve and advance corporate responsibility.

Sustainable Investment in China

A quarterly newsletter will help investors in China understand how sustainable investing can mitigate business risk and create opportunities for greater financial as well as social and environmental returns.

Sustainability Matters 

Snapshots of our impact working with business to create a just and sustainable world.

 BSR member-only content; valid login required.

Share Your Thoughts

Please note, all comments are subject to moderation.



About the Author(s)

David Korngold

David Korngold , Manager, Advisory Services

With experience in international management consulting for global corporations, David works with companies on a wide range of sustainability and corporate responsibility issues... Read more →


John Hodges

John Hodges , Director, Financial Services

With 20 years of sustainable finance experience, John leads BSR's financial services practice, which assists banks, investment managers, insurance companies, private equity firms, and financial information and technology companies to improve the sustainability of their corporate operations, implement new approaches to socially responsible investing, and manage environmental, social, and governance (ESG) risks... Read more →